Reality
Check: a teacher educator's journey into K-12 schools in search of the
roadblocks to successful technology integration
It is
important for teacher educator's to continually evaluate their curriculum and
methods to see how it aligns with the needs of K-12 students and schools. This
is especially important in the area of technology use in education where using
last year's curriculum and methods could handicap new teachers as they
interview and go into the classroom. This is a report on a self-study
autoethnography from my visits starting Fall 2015 into schools, classrooms,
computer labs, and professional development sessions.
There are
questions related to both best practices and practicability that need to be
answered and these questions became part of my observational framework. After
revisiting my philosophy of teaching I started my observations and note taking.
The
observations will be in a variety of school districts, rural, urban, suburban
in Western Washington. The
observational notes will be annotated for connections to my teaching and to
current theories, then the data will be analyzed for themes and answers to the
questions from the pre-observational phase.
In order to
start with the most current research I read through OECD’s recently published extensive report Students, Computers and
Learning: Making the Connection
in 2015 of an comparison of the digital skills of students internationally. A
primary finding is that students from countries that are heavily invested in
technology do not have higher test scores. For my research I believe the
possible interpretations to their findings provide useful points to
investigate. They write:
One
interpretation of all of this is that building deep conceptual understanding
and higher order thinking require intensive teacher-student interactions, and
technology sometimes distracts from this valuable human engagement. Another
interpretation is that we have not yet become good enough at the kinds of
pedagogies that make the most of technology: that adding 21st century
technologies to 20th century teaching practices will just dilute the
effectiveness of teaching. (p.5)
So why isn’t technology, that we depend on so much outside of
school, able to make changes in schools. After years of watching cycles of new
technologies being introduced with claims of bringing learning to the next
level but never producing the results that are significant for large numbers of
students I wanted to reexamine the underlying assumptions for possible
explanations. As I started observing and thought about the complexity of the
problem of technology use in K-12 education I found a paper by Larry Cuban. In
his paper he analyzes errors policymakers commit as they try to “improve”
teaching. I believe that his conclusions about school reform in general apply
to the addition of technology to education as a solution to bring about or be a
contributing factor in the changes that are needed.
I am observing with two of his conclusions in mind, complexity of
the education system and mistaken assumptions. First, Cuban explains that there
is a lack of understanding of the difference between a complicated system and a
complex one. He writes:
The answer, then, to the
so-what question is: at the minimum, know that working in a complex system
means adapting to changes, dealing with conflicts, and constant learning. These
are natural, not aberrations. Know further that reform designs borrowed from
complicated systems and imposed from the top in complex systems will hardly
make a dent in the daily work of those whose job is convert policy into action.
(footnote 8)
The introduction of
technology into education tends to follow a business model, one used for a
complicated system when there needs to be an understanding of the complexity of
the system. Observations in schools can reveal much about the complexity of the
system and the areas where further thought, planning or support need to be
added in order for the goals of improving learning to be reached.
The other area that I see
in my observations has to do with mistaken assumptions. A prominent example is
the mistaken belief that preparing students with 21st century skills
also prepares them to achieve high scores on standardized tests. Other include
the continuing assumption that because technology is commonly used in the world
outside schools it can be used in similar ways within the complex system that
is school. So many schools that I’ve visited have increased available
technology without added the supports systems needed to make it usable within
the classroom. Or in other cases the schools have added so many students and
tasks to the teachers job that the energy needed to add one more thing to their
job is unsustainable for the majority of teachers.
My observations are leading
me to an increased understanding of the complexity of today’s education systems
as well as a need to better understand what is working, what is not working and
what we can do both at the micro and macro levels to make a difference. I hope
to share these findings in a variety of ways as part of the effort to use technology
in a truly useful and effective way to improve more students’ ability to be
prepared for life in the 21st century.
Cuban, L. (2013). Why so
many structural changes in schools and so little reform in teaching practice?
Journal of Educational Administration, 51(2), 109-125.
doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/09578231311304661
OECD (2015), Students, Computers and Learning: Making the
Connection, PISA, OECD Publishing. http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264239555-en
Puentedura, R. (2013,
January 7). Technology In Education: A Brief Introduction. Retrieved October
19, 2015, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rMazGEAiZ9c
Rosenberg, J. (n.d.). TPACK.ORG (M. Koehler, Ed.).
Retrieved October 19, 2015, from http://www.tpack.org/
No comments:
Post a Comment