Tuesday, November 17, 2015

notes on the Adult learner

The Adult Learner: The definitive classic in Adult education and Human Resources Devleopment by Malcom S. Knowles, Holton and Swanson  5th ed.

The first five chapters cover the history of learning theory, theories of learning, adult learning, theories of teaching. Chapter 6 is about HRD Human resource development - adults create and implement their own learning

Androgogy assumptions
These start with the premise that adults need to know why they need to learn something, that they have a concept of being responsible for their own decisions, that they have more and different experiences that effect their learning, they need to be ready to learn, need to see connection to their life, internal motivation is more important than external.

Androgogy in Practice
 WPW whole part whole
At the beginning an present overview, make connections, seeing the value can increase motivation
Parts is instruction on content
Conclusion is the second whole, can be application, practice, reflection

My reflection is that with teacher education it is important to follow some of the principles as I teach, but also to help my students see how this differs from pedagogy. another interesting addition is Heutagogy which I think would be useful as we look at self-learning models and possibly MOOCs



Monday, October 19, 2015

SITE 2016 proposal


Reality Check: a teacher educator's journey into K-12 schools in search of the roadblocks to successful technology integration

It is important for teacher educator's to continually evaluate their curriculum and methods to see how it aligns with the needs of K-12 students and schools. This is especially important in the area of technology use in education where using last year's curriculum and methods could handicap new teachers as they interview and go into the classroom. This is a report on a self-study autoethnography from my visits starting Fall 2015 into schools, classrooms, computer labs, and professional development sessions.
There are questions related to both best practices and practicability that need to be answered and these questions became part of my observational framework. After revisiting my philosophy of teaching I started my observations and note taking. The observations will be in a variety of school districts, rural, urban, suburban in Western Washington. The observational notes will be annotated for connections to my teaching and to current theories, then the data will be analyzed for themes and answers to the questions from the pre-observational phase.

In order to start with the most current research I read through OECD’s recently  published extensive report Students, Computers and Learning: Making the Connection in 2015 of an comparison of the digital skills of students internationally. A primary finding is that students from countries that are heavily invested in technology do not have higher test scores. For my research I believe the possible interpretations to their findings provide useful points to investigate. They write:
One interpretation of all of this is that building deep conceptual understanding and higher order thinking require intensive teacher-student interactions, and technology sometimes distracts from this valuable human engagement. Another interpretation is that we have not yet become good enough at the kinds of pedagogies that make the most of technology: that adding 21st century technologies to 20th century teaching practices will just dilute the effectiveness of teaching. (p.5)

So why isn’t technology, that we depend on so much outside of school, able to make changes in schools. After years of watching cycles of new technologies being introduced with claims of bringing learning to the next level but never producing the results that are significant for large numbers of students I wanted to reexamine the underlying assumptions for possible explanations. As I started observing and thought about the complexity of the problem of technology use in K-12 education I found a paper by Larry Cuban. In his paper he analyzes errors policymakers commit as they try to “improve” teaching. I believe that his conclusions about school reform in general apply to the addition of technology to education as a solution to bring about or be a contributing factor in the changes that are needed.

I am observing with two of his conclusions in mind, complexity of the education system and mistaken assumptions. First, Cuban explains that there is a lack of understanding of the difference between a complicated system and a complex one. He writes:
The answer, then, to the so-what question is: at the minimum, know that working in a complex system means adapting to changes, dealing with conflicts, and constant learning. These are natural, not aberrations. Know further that reform designs borrowed from complicated systems and imposed from the top in complex systems will hardly make a dent in the daily work of those whose job is convert policy into action. (footnote 8)
The introduction of technology into education tends to follow a business model, one used for a complicated system when there needs to be an understanding of the complexity of the system. Observations in schools can reveal much about the complexity of the system and the areas where further thought, planning or support need to be added in order for the goals of improving learning to be reached.

The other area that I see in my observations has to do with mistaken assumptions. A prominent example is the mistaken belief that preparing students with 21st century skills also prepares them to achieve high scores on standardized tests. Other include the continuing assumption that because technology is commonly used in the world outside schools it can be used in similar ways within the complex system that is school. So many schools that I’ve visited have increased available technology without added the supports systems needed to make it usable within the classroom. Or in other cases the schools have added so many students and tasks to the teachers job that the energy needed to add one more thing to their job is unsustainable for the majority of teachers.

My observations are leading me to an increased understanding of the complexity of today’s education systems as well as a need to better understand what is working, what is not working and what we can do both at the micro and macro levels to make a difference. I hope to share these findings in a variety of ways as part of the effort to use technology in a truly useful and effective way to improve more students’ ability to be prepared for life in the 21st century.

Cuban, L. (2013). Why so many structural changes in schools and so little reform in teaching practice? Journal of Educational Administration, 51(2), 109-125. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/09578231311304661

OECD (2015), Students, Computers and Learning: Making the Connection, PISA, OECD Publishing. http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264239555-en

Puentedura, R. (2013, January 7). Technology In Education: A Brief Introduction. Retrieved October 19, 2015, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rMazGEAiZ9c

Rosenberg, J. (n.d.). TPACK.ORG (M. Koehler, Ed.). Retrieved October 19, 2015, from http://www.tpack.org/

Sunday, October 18, 2015

Digital teaching fluency

What do you call the ability of a teacher to be able to teach with an iPad ? I was able to visit three classrooms last week where the teachers were able to use an iPad for teaching as easily as most teachers use a whiteboard or a doccam. This is not the same as being able to use an iPad but means that the iPad was used automatically, it was inconspicuous. To use technology most effectively it needs to become this tool that we don't have to stop and worry with any time that we want to use it.

I love the word automaticity. Automaticity /ˌɔːtəməˈtɪsɨti/ is the ability to do things without occupying the mind with the low-level details required, allowing it to become an automatic response pattern or habit. It is usually the result of learning, repetition, and practice.

For a teacher to want to use a tool they must acquire automaticity. Each teacher was using the iPad differently, showing assignments, projecting documents, asking the students to work download and work on assigned problems. This is an important step in the process of teachers having students use technology beyond review. 

I also learned a little about the structure that allowed this to happen. The school has provided a supporting foundation in infrastructure, technical support, pedagogical support and encouraging practices. I hope to learn more about how this happened and what this means for student learning. 

Having seen a variety of other schools and classrooms with technology that was not in use during my observation it was as important to learn how this being done as what was happening. These other classrooms had good teachers, some technology available, but were lacking some of the supports needed. The limiting factors were almost all beyond the teachers control. 

I expect that as I investigate further I will find that it isn't just a single piece that can be added that makes the difference but a complex web of support that is needed.

Wednesday, October 7, 2015

Coding

Codes

school or level
p primary
i intermediate
m middle
h high
o other

r rural
s suburban
u urban

observations in order

page

example

pr5.2
could be Tenino Primary the 5th observation that I've done, second page

left side
C&I top
Management, assessment bottom
right side
Technology
Other



How to code the observations

As I wrote notes during the observation I was already sorting the data. Need to mark this as motivating, need to connect this to organization, this goes to both C&I and management. The first decision is whether to type the notes up first or to put tabs on the note paper. Should I color code the stickies? I am so bad with using color coding, I always forget what I am using each color for and then run out of colors.

Second idea, scan the notes, save as jpg or pdf, add codes to side

update
I've decided to tape notes to 11x17 sheet and add notes to side. Also coding system so that I can track but the coded notes will be separate so, unidentifiable.  This is especially important for observations of teaching that I may have negative comments about. The original notes will not be part of my online blog, just my analysis and questions will be here. There is also a spreadsheet that will include basic information on each observation; things like rural, suburban, urban and grade level.

Early thoughts on the observations

I started my observations on Sept. 24th and I've now visited 7 classrooms. My overall reaction is that I am having a wonderful time, love getting to spend time with the students, and observing teachers. I've visited 2nd, 3rd, 4/5, 5, 6, 7 & 8. The teachers are putting so much energy and thought into their teaching. I've only been in one classroom that had management problems and that was also the classroom that was primarily teacher talking. Each class that I've been in I want to go back, see what happened next, how they did on the quiz or what happened next. Already thinking about how I might be able to continue visiting in the spring.

I've taken pages of notes and will be going back over them carefully analyzing for connections to our program and specifically the courses that I teach. My first overview will be obvious connections and then I'll go back and look for learning theory and more dispositions. So I'm mostly looking at pedagogy, management, assessment and technology. I should take my camera and ask to take pictures of the classrooms for good organization and management (without students of course).

So far the thing that's been most obvious is academic language. To succeed at CCSS the students have to start speaking the language of the subjects. Most of the teachers are including academic language, but for the students to become fluent they will require a lot of scaffolding. My favorite example was seeing 6th graders do the latitude-longitude dance. During the geography quiz I could see them making the motions to help them remember. In another class they were learning to speak Algebra, they weren't fluent yet but the teacher was encouraging them to start using the correct terms.

Although I haven't seen much technology use by the students yet all of the teachers have doc-cams. This is something that all of the faculty could make sure that our students are using the doc-cams efficiently and effectively. I did observe in one classroom that has 10 iPads so groups of students could use them. This class has already started creating movies using several different apps. The question that I didn't get to ask the teacher was how much time she has to put into making sure that they are ready for use. The major concern and reason for student use is so that they will be ready to take the standardized tests.

I'm also seeing lots of challenges that the teachers face. Some are school created like a middle school teacher with 180 students in 6 classes, with one class of 43. Classrooms that don't have enough space for backpacks and movement and schedules that take large chunks of time for taking tests. Students with learning differences and a wide range of abilities or background knowledge take planning and teaching time. Even at 2nd grade the reading range is great.

Thursday, September 24, 2015

Thoughts on my first observation

Waiting

It's hard to do. Maybe not as hard as it once was. Something about going into a new place, being around people I don't know, trying not to look lost.

Or is it the fact that it's a school. I had so many dreams for many years about being lost in a school building. That hangs on hidden but still there. I remember all of those dreams or at least the impression of the dreams. The feeling of being late and walking down long corridors and empty stairways,  the dreadful feeling of being in an unknown, unfriendly place that I don't want to be in. Looking at every door, until I wake up.

All of this because I arrived early and didn't want to go into the office until the students and parents had thinned out.

After the observation

Very friendly, friendly lady at the front welcoming students, parents, staff and me. Front office sent a student to show me how to get to the room. Friendly teacher and students.

As I left a student turned and said, "I'm glad that you came. I don't feel so alone now." Maybe the red hair. never had that greeting before.

Wednesday, September 23, 2015

My teaching - Hidden Gems

First thoughts

My primary goal as I teach is to prepare future teachers so that they can facilitate learning for all of their students. There is a lot packed into that goal. Other concepts may be part of the objectives that I've listed. The goal and objectives mean that they will need to consider what teachers do today realistically and decide if it fits with their vision of a vocation for themselves.

They must learn content, work on dispositions, and practice skills. For some of my students who are second career or non-traditional students it may mean that they will have to be willing to learn a new career language, become a novice. Some of my traditional students may need to see how complex teaching is and decide if they are ready to put in the work needed.

Objectives
The future teacher will be able to:
1. differentiate instruction
2. use developmentally and culturally appropriate strategies
3. plan lessons that have learning targets that are differentiated and accessible for their students
4. organize their classroom, materials, and time
5. use technology to facilitate learning
6. use formative assessment continually throughout the lesson
7. advocate for their students
8. take care of their physical and mental health
9. learn with their students
10. enjoy teaching



Coby, Aaron
Wed 9/23/2015 11:41 AM
To:
Hill, Belinda;
You replied on 9/23/2015 11:57 AM.
Hi Belinda!
Your IRB proposal has been approved.  I’ll send the official letter via campus mail.
Good luck!
Aaron 
 
Sent IRB proposal on 9/15
 

Observations


As I prepare for my first observation tomorrow I need to clarify what I will be observing. I have my general goals of checking to see how what I teach matches what teachers need but this is not where I say "I'll know it when I see it"

I have created a form and spreadsheet to track all of the context information, teacher, grade, subject, school, etc. I thought about using a more complex form for the observation but I really like writing the notes out on paper. The general data will allow me to look at who and where more easily. Also it will be a good contact sheet.

Categories that I'm interested in:

physical environment
  1. # of students, m/f
  2. noise level
  3. space for work
  4. organization
  5. para/other adults
  6. populations
learning environment
  1. friendly
  2. respect
  3. feedback
  4. management/discipline
technology
  1. teacher computers/tablet
  2. student computers/tablets
  3. doc cam
  4. Smartboard
  5. other
instruction
  1. types of instruction
  2. directions, written, verbal, on handouts
  3. individual, whole class, group, cooperative
  4. pace
  5. feedback
  6. formative assessments
interaction
  1. questions, to students, by students, wait time
  2. discussion
  3. peer to peer
organization


Monday, September 21, 2015

Letter to teacher


Dear Teacher,

Thank you for allowing me to come into your classroom for an observation.

I am working on a research self-study that I call ‘Reality Check’. It is about my teaching, evaluating what I have been teaching and checking for adjustments that I may need to make so that I can better prepare future teachers for the classroom.

I will be happy to share my notes, observations and answer any questions that you have. I want to be clear that I am not critiquing your teaching. My purpose is to see what is happening in classrooms today and make connections to what I teach. My notes on the observation will become part of my research evidence but there will be no identifying connections to you or your students in any of my final work.

If you want to contact me I can be reached at belinda@stmartin.edu or 360 278 3111.

Sunday, September 20, 2015

References


Adams, T., Jones, S., & Ellis, C. (2015). Autoethnography: Understanding qualitative research. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Bean, J. (2011). Engaging ideas : The professor's guide to integrating writing, critical thinking, and active learning in the classroom. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Britzman, D. (2003). Practice makes practice a critical study of learning to teach (Rev. ed.). Albany: State University of New York Press.
Ellis, C. (2004). The ethnographic I: A methodological novel about autoethnography. Walnut Creek, CA: AltaMira Press.
Georghiades, P. (2004). From the general to the situated: Three decades of metacognition. International Journal of Science Education, 365-383.
Lassonde, C., Galman, S., & Kosnik, C. (2009). Self-study research methodologies for teacher educators. Rotterdam: Sense.
Marzano, R., & Pickering, D. (2001). Classroom instruction that works: Research-based strategies for increasing student achievement. Alexandria, Va.: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.
Nucci, L. (2001). Education in the moral domain. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Pew, S. (2007). Androgogy and Pedagogy as Foundational Theory for Student Motivation in Higher Education. InSight a Journal of Scholarly Teaching, 2(1), 14-25.
Samaras, A. (2011). Self-study teacher research improving your practice through collaborative inquiry. Los Angeles: SAGE.
Simpson, D. (2010). Professional Spirit among Teachers. In Teachers, leaders, and schools essays by John Dewey. Carbondale, Ill.: Southern Illinois University Press.

conference proposal


Castle Conference Proposal 2015

Context of the Study

Reality Check: a teacher educator’s journey into K-12 schools

This is autoethnographical self-study research that investigates the problem of whether what I have been teaching future teachers prepares them to become effective teachers. An effective teacher described by John Dewey “is possessed by a recognition of the responsibility for the constant study of school room work, the constant study of children, of methods, of subject matter in its various adaptations to pupils”. Although much of what I have to cover in my courses has to do with what they have to know to meet the requirements for teacher certification I also want them to learn how to create a learning environment that facilitates learning for all students. The themes that I identify in the evidence that I collect in K-12 classrooms and activities can be used to assess and inform my teaching.

I have been teaching future teachers since 1985 and working as a teacher educator since 1998. I am frequently asked by former students to visit their classrooms but have never had time to do it in an in-depth research study. Fall of 2015 is a sabbatical semester and provides the opportunity for me to do this.

Theoretical framework

The framework for my teaching and therefore for this study is rooted in the philosophy of John Dewey, influenced by developmental theorists, and includes knowledge currently identified as ‘best practices’. Most of my teaching focuses on how to facilitate learning, helping my students understand how to use concepts of developmental theories (Vygotsky, Piaget, information processing, Nucci) and how to use ‘best practices’ to plan (Wiggins and McTighe) and how to teach (Marzano,et al). This study is framed by Dewey’s ideas that teachers are professionals and the role of teacher educators is to help new teachers make the transition between the theory and practice of higher education and the real world of K-12 schools where they will become professionals.


Aim/Objectives of the study

The problem is that I think I have become a good teacher educator my evidence for that claim is limited. I know what I am trying to teach and see evidence of what I teach from my students and my former students. I hear from students and former students that they are using things that they learned from me. However I want to know more about how what I teach and the knowledge, skills and dispositions that my students learn function in K-12 schools today.

Primary question: how does my philosophy of education work within the context of K-12 schools today?
Secondary question: what do I need to change to assist my students to transition into the teaching profession?

Method(s)
I will use self-study methodology with autoethnography

Observations
I plan on visiting a variety of classrooms, schools, teacher training sessions to observe and take notes. These will be schools located in the geographical area where I live and teach in the Pacific NW. Some classrooms and training activities will be those of former students and some will be teachers that I have met or worked with in the past.

Although the observational notes will be used for my autoethnography I will not be referring specifically to any of the teachers or their students. I will ask questions, discuss my observations and share my notes with these teachers. They will be encouraged to give feedback but are not listed as critical friends because of the time involvement that is required in that role. Sharing my findings with the teachers I observe and with others will help to demonstrate the trustworthiness that is needed for self-study. There will also be a tracking form with contextual information that will not be publically shared but can be used as I analyze and look for themes.

Critical friends
Two colleagues have agreed to assist in this research in the role of critical friend. The first is a teacher educator of 30 plus years that I have team taught with. He also teaches several of the foundation courses that I teach. The second is the director of our Master’s in Education program. Her feedback will be valuable since we are considering self-study as a method of research for our Master’s students.

Autoethnography
I am foremost a reflective teacher educator. Before I ever learned about autoethnography I wanted to use my reflections on my teaching to improve my teaching and to improve the teacher education program at my university. Autoethnography allows me to reflect and improve for myself, and for my students, for my college and for the wider audience of teacher educators who need research to show what they are doing.

Analysis is ongoing throughout the process. It started as I conceptualized the study. I am keeping an online-journal throughout the process. The observational will be shared with those observed and then the observational write-ups which will not contain identifying information will be shared with my critical friends and will become part of my final product.

Outcomes This study was conceptualized in summer 2015, observations will take place fall 2015, analysis of data will take place fall 2015 and spring 2016. The final product of this study is conceived of as a non-linear online account that can be searched by others to learn more about different aspects of the study.

There are several outcomes that I expect from this study.
1.     I hope to learn more about how my teaching philosophy connects with K-12 education
2.     Provide an example for Master’s students in our program of a self-study research project related to their teaching
3.     Help those working with our Master’s students evaluate self-study as a method for their final project
4.     Provide information to our College of Education and Counseling Psychology about what is currently needed in K-12 education to help our students create a strong foundation for their future work
5.     Provide research for the teacher education community of the efficacy of our work within K-12 education

References see separate post

Tuesday, September 15, 2015

Abstract

Reality Check: a teacher educator's journey into K-12 schools

first draft of abstract

This is an autoethnographical self-study research project that investigates the problem of whether what I have been teaching future teachers prepares them to become effective teachers. An effective teacher is described by John Dewey as “is possessed by a recognition of the responsibility for the constant study of school room work, the constant study of children, of methods, of subject matter in its various adaptations to pupils”. Although much of what I have to cover in my courses has to do with what they have to know to meet the requirements for teacher certification I also want them to learn how to create a learning environment that facilitates learning for all students. The themes that contribute to facilitating learning  in K-12 classrooms and activities can be used to assess and inform my teaching.
Timeline for research project

Spring 2015 - thought about all of the things that I might want to research if given the chance. thinking particularly on the importance of reflection to teachers and how to help them develop that skill. Continued with the idea of reflection but learned about autethnography.

Summer 2015 -  Started reading and studying about autoethnography. Learned about self-study from a friend. How did I miss this all these years. There's an AERA Self-Study sig, what a surprise. Started reading about self-study and realized that it can be done as an autoethnography.

Fall 2015
September -
  • Read more about both autoethnography and self-study
  • Started going through the steps outlined in A Samaras textbook on Self-study
  • Wrote IRB application (I think it should be exempt)
  • Writing proposal for Castle Conf.
  • Write proposal for SITE
  • Started finding Critical Friends (important part for  self-study research)
  • Write notes, abstract and overview of my project, checklist of observation
October & November -
Visit classrooms, take notes, find themes
Write

December - Review notes, write, create project website

Spring 2016- continue visiting classrooms, decide on next steps
SITE conference

Summer - ?



Notes on Self-Study Teacher Research:improving your practice through collaborative inquiry pt. 1
by Anastasia P. Samaras

This book is written and formatted for teachers and pre-service teachers.

The 6 W's of Self-study reasearch
What and why (chapter 1)
Self-study research allows you to openly ask questions about your teaching practice.

ex. 1
1. I wonder about  the effectiveness of my teaching because it's important that I'm not wasting my students time.

2. Why is this issue important to you? What experiences and perspectives brought you to ask this question? This is important to me because teacher education is being questioned and blamed for poor teachers based on low standardized scores of their students. I think that I am doing a good job but would like supporting evidence.

3. Who would benefit from addressing this question? It would be a benefit to me, to CECP, to my students, and to the profession.

Critical Friends. I've copied a section of the book and linked it for easy reference for my Critical Friends

Self Study Research is:
  1. Personal situated inquiry
  2. Critical collaborative inquiry
  3. Improved learning
  4. A transparent and systematic research process
  5. Knowledge generation and presentation
I like the idea of self-study research for teachers for a number of reasons:
  1. I like qualitative research because it is more wholistic, shows context, reveals complexity
  2. It has not been accepted well by many academics, politicians, etc. so it is seen as less stringent and rigorous and also a less useful method of research. I think it is actually more useful. While it doesn't give absolute answers it reveals more to think about.
  3. Self-study is useful for teachers. I think that reflection is an important skill for teachers but self-study takes reflection and uses it both to answer questions and to broaden knowledge for a wider audience.
From A Samaras p. 17 "Self-study of teaching practices begins to build muscle for professional development as a lifelong process." What a boon to teaching that would be if teachers saw that they can solve their problems, improve their teaching and contribute to education reform.

Overview of the Self-study research process (chapter 2)

This chapter gives a sample planner and timeline and an example. So before even explaining the history of self-study, the community, etc.  (chapter 3) it lets students know what would be involved, lets them see how it might be done, helps them make a connection to the topic.

The Self-study methodology (chapter 4)

This chapter lists many different ways that a self-study research project can be done. I am doing an autoethnography (see notes on autoethnography).

Recursive nature and hermeneutics
Hermeneutic is "a research process whereby the researcher shifts forward and backward through the data with no pre-determined assumptions to allow for the emergence of seemingly unrelated ideas and part-whole relationships" (see my timeline)










Monday, September 14, 2015

Notes on the book Autoethnography by Tony E Adams, Stacy Jones and Carolyn Ellis

I wonder if either Tony or Stacy are part of the characters in Ethnographic I by Carolyn Harris?

This is a short book and written with the authors stories but id does contain a few important points so I'll note those.

The introduction begins with a quote "we tell stories in order to live" by Joan Didion. I also just found a quote by Pablo Picasso "We all know that Art is not truth. Art is a lie that makes us realize the truth, at least the truth that is given to us to understand." I think both of these have something to do with why I want to do an autoethnography. I want to say something about reality but I want to do it in a way that I choose and I want it to be something that others can read and learn something from.

AUTOETHNOGRAPHY is a research method that (chapter I)

  • Uses a researcher's personal experience to describe and critique cultural beliefs, practices and experiences.
  • Acknowledges and values a researcher's relationships with others.
  • Uses deep and careful self-reflection - typically referred to as "reflexivity" - to name and interrogate the intersections between self and society, the particular and the general, the personal and the political.
  • Shows" people in the process of figuring out what to do, how to live, and the meaning of their struggles.
  • Balances intellectual and methodological rigor, emotion, and creativity
  • Strives for social justice to make life better. 
Yes, I agree with all of the above.

Core Ideals (chapter 2)

Autoethnography is a qualitative method - it offers nuanced, complex, and specific knowledge about particular lives, experiences, and relationships rather than general information about large groups of people.  

Autoethnographers typically
  • Foreground personal experiences in research and writing
  • Illustrate sense-making processes
  • Use and show reflexivity
  • Illustrate insider knowledge of a cultural phenomenom /experience
  • Describe and critique cultural norms, experiences, and practices
  • Seek responses from audiences
Doing autoethnography (chapter 3)

Ethical considerations

"Process consent" happens when researchers check in with participants during each stage of a project, from design to fieldwork to drafting and sharing or an autoethnographic text, to ensure particiapnts' continued willingness to take part in a project." it is dynamic and ongoing

Ethics of consequences

Kim Etherington terms the "ethics of consequences" - that is, accounting for the positive and negative reasons for participating in a study and acknowledging and working to minimize the power differentials and varying goals that inevitably exist between researchers and participants.

Protecting the Privacy and Identities of participants 

Relational ethics
 ...a relational ethic "recognizes and values mutual respect, dignity and connectedness between researcher and researched, and between researchers and the communities in which they live and work."

Interpreting meaning and analyzing fieldwork

It is difficult to separate doing authoethnography from writing autoethnography

Representing autoethnography (chapter 4)

This chapter is about how to put the pieces together. It would be worth re-reading later.

 Evaluating autoethnography

Goals
  1. Making contributions to knowledge
  2. Valuing the personal and experiential
  3. Demonstrating the power, craft, and responsibilities of stories and storytelling
  4. Taking a relationally responsible approach to research practice and representation
 
All quotes are in purple.





 Today is the first day of my notes for auto ethanol graffiti (this is how the voice recognition software write out autothnography.

I started reading the book self-study teacher research and going through the steps needed for working on myself study the first thing I did was answer the questions the second thing I did is think about who I would asked to be on my critical team I will be meeting with the list I came up with is Paul  Linda Maier, possibly some of the students that I observed such as Cheri Dusek, Catherine Cullum, Glenda Evans

There are so many things that I'd rather do than write. And there are so many ideas to put down that it's hard to decide where to start.

Also somewhere I have some hand written notes that I started earlier and can't find. So this may not be the very beginning.

Beginning the journey

“Good autoethnographic writing is truthful, vulnerable, evocative, and therapeutic,” C Ellis

 Reality check: a teacher educators journey into K-12 education

I want to go into classrooms and schools and find out if what I teach future teachers helps them to become an affective teacher and an effective teacher.  I'm excited and I'm wondering and what if I find I have been teaching the wrong things .  I don't think I will find that I've been teaching the wrong things but I hope to find better and more effective ways for them to facilitate learning .

Facilitating learning,  I always start out my beginning class explaining the difference between teaching and facilitating learning. You can teach without anyone learning.  You can teach  without regard for your students.  Teaching is something that is about the teacher.  Facilitating learning is focused on your students.

There are so many things to know whether beginning there are so many things that have to go into that first course.  They have to learn about all of the acronyms in the vocabulary, the standards, the expectations, the hard work. They also need to understand that teaching is about more than content and methods. It's about environment.

I think that's the part that I want them to leave with, the environment. Not just the physical environment but the social, emotional and moral environment as well.